Home > News >

Challenge to Hunterston coal-fired plant defeated in court

4 October

A legal challenge against plans for a new £3bn coal-fired power station near Largs at Hunterston has been turned down by the courts.

Environmental groups had launched the challenge against plans for the new coal-fired power station .

The challenge was led by Marco McGinty from Saltcoats, who mounted a legal challenge with the help of RSPB, WWF and Friends of the Earth.

A judicial review challenged a decision by the Scottish government to include the planned facility at Hunterston in the National Planning Framework, which meant campaigners could not challenge the need for the plant - only matters such as the site and design.

However, judges ruled that a consultation process undertaken by the developer, Ayrshire Coal, had been sufficient.

The proposals by Ayrshire Power, which is owned by Peel Energy Ltd, are for a site between the existing Clydeport coal handling facility at the Hunterston Terminal and the Hunterston B nuclear power plant.

You can read more on this story here on the BBC website.

What do you think of the decision? Post your comments and have your say here on s1largs


15 October | 9:46:59

Sandy Morton says

I originally posted this on s1millport but I feel that it also has a relevance to Largs.

 

I deeply regret that most of the comments which I would make about this project would be censored.

However I trust and hope that the following are reasonable and within the bounds of possibility and responsibility.

The North Ayrshire coast already has a suffiency of visual disasters.  The coal port is not attractive and is a visual intrusion into the visual amenity of the area.  Hunterston B is possibly necessary as a means of power but cannot be seen as attractive.  Hunterston A is a visual obscenity and should have been clad in a visually reponsible material.

The current proposal for a coal fired disaster are unreasonable and totally against the hopeful infrastructure of this area.

From Millport it will be a very large blot on the tourist landscape.

The transport infrastructure on the mainland surrounding it is incapable of coping with the vast amount of road traffic which will have to happen - either by employees (I have absolutely nothing against people gaining employment) or by the vastly increased amount of commercial traffic.

On the environmental issue.  Is it really necessary to heighten the chimney with the attendant visual impact or is this only to carry the noxious fumes a wee bit higher into the atmosphere so that someone else will have to suffer them?

Take it away and leave us alone - we have a very nearly attractive place to live and work in and we would like that to continue.

26 November | 11:14:21

Graham Green says

A concrete monstrosity  visible from most areas of the lower Cyde with 100's of extra train movements monthly on a currently "dodgy" line, Carbon capture ( not even perfected) with residues to be pumped to Liverpool / Morecombe Bay, 1,000's of tons of ash to be moved weekly,a proportion of which will be to local landfill,  very few jobs in comparison to our current power station, how can this be good for a high profile tourist area?

Have your say...

Add your own comment

Add

You need to be logged in to add news & pictures. If you haven't already, it's quick & easy to Sign up.

Sorry, there were some problems with your request

Please check that the email address you are using is the same one that you signed up with. If you have forgotten your password we can send you a reminder.

Sign In
  4. Forgotten Password?

Sorry, there were some problems with your request

Please check that the email address you are using is the same one that you signed up with.

Password reminder

  1. If you have forgotten your password, simply enter the email address associated with your account below and we will send you a link to reset it.

    Please note for security reasons the link will expire within 1 hour. After that you will need to request another link.

  4. <<Return to Login

Your sign in details have been retrieved and an email is on its way to you!

<<Return to Login

Contribute

  1. By posting on s1largs you’re agreeing to abide by our Posting Policy. Your email address won’t be displayed to the public.

  1. Here's your chance to make sure your contribution is exactly as you'd like it.

  3. Your photos will be uploaded when you click 'Send it'

    Your video will be uploaded when you click 'Send it'

    Your photos and video will be uploaded when you click 'Send it'

  4. By clicking 'send it' you’re agreeing to abide by our Posting Policy.

Tell everyone your news

If it’s topical in Largs, this is the place for it.

Remember that news doesn't just mean crime and politics – a golden wedding, a new baby, or a personal achievement are news to any community.

Add

You need to be logged in to add news & pictures. If you haven't already, it's quick & easy to Sign up.

Sorry, there were some problems with your request

Please check that the email address you are using is the same one that you signed up with. If you have forgotten your password we can send you a reminder.

Sign In
  4. Forgotten Password?

Sorry, there were some problems with your request

Please check that the email address you are using is the same one that you signed up with.

Password reminder

  1. If you have forgotten your password, simply enter the email address associated with your account below and we will send you a link to reset it.

    Please note for security reasons the link will expire within 1 hour. After that you will need to request another link.

  4. <<Return to Login

Your sign in details have been retrieved and an email is on its way to you!

<<Return to Login

Contribute

  1. Please make sure what you’re adding is news. If it's an event, you must also add it to our What's On section before it'll be allowed here. History and advertising have their own sections, too.

    Posting Tips

  4. If your contribution is about a specific location, please enter the nearest postcode (if known)

  1. Here's your chance to make sure your contribution is exactly as you'd like it.

  3. Your photos will be uploaded when you click 'Send it'

    Your video will be uploaded when you click 'Send it'

    Your photos and video will be uploaded when you click 'Send it'

  4. By clicking 'send it' you’re agreeing to abide by our Posting Policy.

In the News

Want a site like this for your community? Suggest a new location
© Herald & Times Group. All rights reserved.
Contact us | Terms of use | Privacy policy | Newsquest Media Group